I spent the weekend at a retreat called Walking Into Fire with three of my favorite teachers: Jennifer Louden, Susan Piver and Patti Digh.
Telling it like it is
Although this was a writing retreat, I found it easy to translate the exercises they shared into processes to help dig into our relationship with money. Here is one exercise Patti taught called ‘Yes, But.‘
Have you ever experienced being stopped dead in your creative tracks by someone responding to your fabulous, world changing idea (or your heart ache) with ‘Yes, but….‘?
It might look something like this. You are having coffee with a dear friend, and the conversation has turned to your job hunting process:
‘Well, I’ve been scouring ads on craigslist and Monster, I’m not making any headway. So I’m thinking about going back to school and changing careers altogether.‘
‘Yes, but you know that takes money and how will you pay the bills? You have a child, you know.’
‘Yes, but I might be able to get a scholarship, and I’ve heard they have childcare.’
‘Yes, but you’ll be in debt, and I know how you hate owing people money, and what if there aren’t any jobs in that field when you graduate? Then what?’
You get the picture. ‘Yes, but…’ kills the conversation, kills possibility, kills creative problem solving.
This also shows up at home with our partners and children, and at work or business with our bosses and employees, as the tendency to say no… not because the real answer is no, but because we don’t trust the process. We don’t trust that playing with ideas is different from agreeing to buy the new car or do the $100k addition to the house. ‘No‘ and ‘Yes, but’ are both ways of buying time, and stalling the creative process, and most of the time it’s not conscious.
I’m here to tell you that there’s a tremendous difference between talking with someone who continually closes the door on your ideas, and someone who opens the door with an invitation to explore, to step into the preposterous, the land of ridiculous possibilities.
What happens if we simply change one word, and make it into ‘Yes, and…‘?
‘I’m not sure what to do… I’ve been unemployed for five months. I’m losing faith. I’m thinking about going back to school.’
‘Yes, and maybe while you are there you’ll meet someone that turns out to be your next boss!’
‘Yes, and I might find what I’m really passionate about, since working in a proctologist’s office clearly isn’t it. Heck, I might as well apply to med school with all that I learned working in the field.’
‘Yes, and you could also do career counseling to explore all the options. You could even create an independent study class with the sole purpose to evaluate your passions and skills and see what jobs combine both.’
‘Yes, and while I’m going to school I could work at Starbucks because they have great benefits, and I could conduct research as I interact with my customers.’
‘Yes, and you then discover there’s a link between the coffee you drink and the jobs you excel at, and you publish a best selling book about it.’
You see? ‘And‘ is an invitation to go exploring. ‘But’ is a judgment that stops you in your tracks, hijacking the creative process.
We ‘yes, but‘ ourselves all the time, and we do it to those we love, believing it’s our job to protect them from themselves or from the big, bad world. We also ‘yes, but‘ because we are afraid of change, we are afraid of the unknown, we are afraid of getting what we want.
Today I invite you to have a conversation with yourself about something you want. Maybe you want to ask for a raise, or you want to start saving for your doctorate and your spouse doesn’t see the point. Maybe you have been thinking about hiring a financial adviser, or starting a Roth IRA. Write the conversation just as I did above. Respond to everything with ‘yes, but’ until you are so frustrated you want to pull your hair out (Okay, stop before any locks land on the floor). Then do the same with ‘Yes, and.’ Let yourself go into the possibilities, as wacky as they may sound.
We didn’t get electricity, microwave ovens, the iPod and YouTube because people said ‘Yes, but.’ Let me know what you discover!
© 2011 Luna Jaffe